Joseph Smith Polygamy: Unpacking The Complex History Of Early Mormon Plural Marriage
The story of Joseph Smith and the practice of polygamy stands as a very complex and often debated part of early Mormon history. It's a subject that brings up a lot of questions for many people, both inside and outside the church. This particular practice, which is more accurately called polygyny—meaning a man having more than one wife—really shaped the early days of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and it continues to be a point of discussion for those looking at American religious history.
For some, understanding Joseph Smith's involvement with plural marriage is about exploring its spiritual and historical setting. It's about looking at how a belief became a commandment and what that meant for the people living through it. This practice, in a way, was quite different from the societal norms of the time, and it certainly created a lot of strong feelings and consequences.
So, we're going to take a look at the intricate details of Joseph Smith's introduction of plural marriage, its theological roots, and the very real impact it had on individuals and the broader community. We'll explore some of the key elements that made this practice so unique and, in some respects, so controversial, even for its time.
Table of Contents
- Joseph Smith: A Glimpse at His Life
- The Beginnings of Plural Marriage
- The Wives of Joseph Smith
- Controversy and Criticism
- The Lasting Impact and Historical Context
- Frequently Asked Questions
Joseph Smith: A Glimpse at His Life
Joseph Smith's life, as a matter of fact, was full of excitement and danger. He seemed to have a liking for risk and the secret nature of things, which perhaps played into how he approached the practice of plural marriage. He was a central figure, and his decisions had a huge influence on the early church.
| Detail | Description |
|---|---|
| Role in Church | Founder and first prophet of the early Mormon church. |
| Character | Appears to have relished risk and the clandestine nature of certain practices. His life, basically, was not short on excitement or peril. |
| Marital Status | Married to Emma Smith, and later, introduced and practiced plural marriage. |
| Legal Troubles | Arrested and charged with various offenses, including adultery and polygamy, particularly in 1838. |
The Beginnings of Plural Marriage
The question of when Joseph Smith first brought up the idea of polygamy is a key part of this whole discussion. It's not a simple timeline, you know, but rather a progression from initial curiosity in the early 1830s to teaching it as a divine command. This website, for instance, is the first online site completely dedicated to exploring this journey, from his early thoughts to his sealings to plural wives.
A Divine Command or Personal Curiosity?
Some accounts suggest that Joseph Smith's interest in plural marriage started as a personal exploration, a sort of curiosity in the early 1830s. However, it eventually became presented as a commandment from the divine. This shift from personal interest to a sacred instruction is a pretty important aspect of how the practice was introduced and accepted by some members of the early church. It's a subtle but significant distinction, really.
The Angel and the Sword
One of the most intense stories surrounding the introduction of plural marriage is the claim that an angel, armed with a sword, threatened Joseph Smith. The angel, so the story goes, insisted that Smith practice plural marriage or face dire consequences. This narrative, quite often, is used to explain the supposed divine pressure behind the implementation of polygamy, suggesting it wasn't a choice but a command that had to be followed, even if it was incredibly difficult.
The Wives of Joseph Smith
The list of Joseph Smith's wives is a very significant part of the historical record, with some sources listing as many as 53 rows of individuals sealed to him. This extensive list includes not only polygynous marriages (one man, multiple wives) but also instances of polyandry, where Smith was sealed to women who were already married to other men. This aspect, too, adds another layer of complexity to the whole situation.
Polyandry and Young Brides
The practice of polyandry within Joseph Smith's plural marriages is a particularly sensitive topic. It means he was, in some cases, sealed to women who were already married to other men, which was quite unusual even within the context of plural marriage. Additionally, some of the individuals sealed to him were very young brides, a detail that has, you know, drawn considerable discussion and concern from historians and the public alike. These details contribute to the intricate and sometimes troubling nature of the practice.
Emma Smith's Experience
Joseph Smith and Emma Smith's relationship is often thought of as a great love story, a picture of a perfect, powerful couple. However, the introduction of polygamy, as you can imagine, placed immense strain on their bond. Emma Smith's feelings about her husband's plural marriages are a crucial part of this history, and her struggles and reactions are often highlighted as a deeply personal aspect of the broader story. It's clear that this practice was a source of great personal difficulty for her, you know, making their love story a bit more complicated than it might first appear.
Controversy and Criticism
From the very beginning, Joseph Smith's practice of polygamy was a source of intense criticism and legal persecution. Outside the church, it was seen as morally wrong and, as a matter of fact, against the law. This widespread disapproval led to many challenges for the early church and its leaders, including arrests and charges.
Outside Persecution
The public's reaction to polygamy was, quite frankly, very strong. In 1838, for instance, Joseph Smith and other church leaders were arrested and faced charges, partly due to the controversies surrounding this practice. The wider American society simply did not accept plural marriage, and this disagreement often turned into legal action and social ostracism. It was a constant battle, basically, against prevailing norms and laws.
Internal Dissent
It wasn't just outsiders who had problems with polygamy. There was, in fact, dissent within the church itself. A newspaper, for example, published its first and only issue criticizing Smith and other church leaders. This paper correctly reported that Smith was practicing polygamy, even marrying the wives of other men. This internal disagreement, you know, eventually led to Smith being charged with adultery and polygamy, showing that the controversy was not just external but also came from within his own community.
The Lasting Impact and Historical Context
The practice of plural marriage, as you might guess, played a really important role in shaping the history of the early Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. It influenced everything from its theology to its social structure and its interactions with the wider American society. Understanding this practice is key to grasping the full story of early Mormonism.
Polygamy Before Smith
It's interesting to note that Mormons were not the first in America to think about plural marriage. In fact, for three centuries before Joseph Smith introduced Mormon "celestial marriage," there were other discussions or practices of plural marriage, often rooted in biblical interpretations. So, while Smith's practice was unique in its specific context and scale, the idea of plural marriage itself wasn't entirely new to the American landscape. It's a bit like saying, you know, the concept existed, but his application of it was truly distinct.
Scholarly Perspectives
Historians today continue to explore and discuss Joseph Smith's polygamy. John Turner, for example, a historian who has written a new biography of Joseph Smith, openly states, "I think the evidence for Joseph’s polygamous sealings is pretty overwhelming." This kind of scholarly consensus helps to clarify the historical facts surrounding the practice. The church itself has also provided new resources, like questions pages on plural marriage, to help people understand this complex part of its past. It's a topic that, apparently, still generates a lot of academic interest and research.
Frequently Asked Questions
When did Joseph Smith first introduce polygamy?
Joseph Smith's initial interest in plural marriage began in the early 1830s. This period marks the start of his exploration into the concept, which later evolved into its public introduction and practice as a commandment within the early Mormon church. The timeline, you know, shows a progression from personal curiosity to an established principle.
Did church leaders lie about practicing polygamy?
Historical accounts indicate that there was, in some respects, a period where the practice of polygamy was kept secret or denied publicly by church leaders. This was often due to the intense criticism and legal persecution they faced. A newspaper, for instance, correctly reported Smith's practice, suggesting that official denials were in place even as the practice was happening, which is a bit complicated.
Did an angel really threaten Joseph with a sword if he didn't practice plural marriage?
According to some accounts within early Mormon history, Joseph Smith claimed that an angel appeared to him with a drawn sword, instructing him to practice plural marriage. This narrative, basically, served as a powerful theological justification for the controversial practice, suggesting it was a divine command rather than a personal choice, even if it sounds quite dramatic.
The complex history of Joseph Smith's polygamy is a significant thread in the tapestry of American religious history. It's a story that includes spiritual beliefs, personal relationships, societal pressures, and profound changes for many people. Understanding this period helps us grasp the full scope of the early Latter-day Saint movement and its lasting legacy. To learn more about religious history on our site, and to explore this page .
The Mormon church finally acknowledges founder Joseph Smith’s polygamy
Mormon leaders admit church founder Joseph Smith practiced polygamy
Mormon leaders admit church founder Joseph Smith practiced polygamy
